Desserts

Below are descriptions of the desserts we offer. If you’re interested in in ordering these desserts, make sure to visit our Desserts to Go page.

Pies:

All pies are made with handmade pie shells.

  • Coconut Cream – homemade custard with coconut with a homemade cream topping
  • Chocolate Cream – homemade chocolate custard with a homemade cream topping
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream—homemade chocolate custard with a peanut butter mixture made with cream cheese
  • Banana Cream—homemade custard with bananas with a homemade cream topping
  • Raspberry Cream—raspberry pie filling with seeds with a homemade cream topping
  • Peanut Butter Cream—peanut butter crumbs, homemade custard with a homemade cream topping
  • Chocolate Banana Cream—homemade chocolate custard with bananas and a homemade cream topping
  • Peanut Butter Silk—Oreo crust with a sweet peanut butter cream cheese filling topped with peanut butter crumbs and chocolate syrup
  • Pumpkin Cream—fresh pumpkin, pudding and spice filling with a homemade cream topping
  • Strawberry or Peach Cream—a sweet cream cheese base with fresh berries or peaches with a sweet flavored gelatin glaze
  • Pumpkin Pie—pumpkin, milk, and spice custard type pie
  • Egg Custard—eggs, sugar and milk custard type pie
  • Coconut Custard—eggs, sugar, milk and fresh coconut custard type pie
  • Lemon Meringue—lemon pie filling with a meringue topping
  • Lemon Cream—homemade lemon cream made with sour cream
  • Key Lime—limes, sugar, eggs, condensed milk cream type pie
  • Lushes—short bread crust with a layer of sweeten cream cheese, layer of pudding with a homemade cream topping
  • Apple Streusel—fresh apples, sugar, spices, cream cheese crumbles baked in pie shell
  • Pecan Pie—pecans, sugar, kero—very gooey type pie
  • Chocolate Pecan Pie—same as pecan pie with chocolate chips added
  • Shoofly—wet bottom molasses type cake (Pennsylvania Dutch type pie)
  • Lemon Sponge—wet bottom lemon type cake pie
  • Chocolate Lava—fudgey brownie like cake with a deep gooey chocolate center
  • Cherry Crumb—homemade sour cherry filling with crumbs
  • Cherry Macaroon—homemade sour cherry filling with a coconut and almond crust
  • Blueberry and Raspberry Crumb—pie filling with a homemade crumb mixture
  • Apple Pie—fresh apples, spices topping with a homemade crumb mixture

Cakes:

  • Chocolate Cake with Peanut Butter frosting—3 layer dark chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting topped with chocolate ganache and chopped peanut butter cups
  • Chocolate Cake with Chocolate frosting—3 layers dark chocolate cake with chocolate frosting topped with chocolate ganache
  • Coconut Cake—3 layers of white cake with white frosting and coconut
  • Red Velvet Cake—3 layers of a red velvet cake (chocolate in taste) with white frosting
  • Carrot Cake—3 layers of carrot cake with cream cheese frosting (with nuts)
  • Banana Cake—3 layers of banana cake with cream cheese frosting
  • Yellow Cake with chocolate frosting—3 layers of yellow cake with a light chocolate frosting
  • Oreo Cake—2 layers of chocolate cake and 1 layer of white cake filled with a whipped cream and Oreo filling topped with white frosting and topped with Oreos
  • Banana Split Cake—1 layer of chocolate cake, 1 layer of strawberry cake, 1 layer of banana cake frosted in white frosting topped with chocolate ganache, cherries and crushed pineapples
  • Peanut Butter Cake with Light chocolate frosting—3 layers of peanut butter cake with light chocolate frosting
  • Mocha Torte—4 layers of thin chocolate cake drenched in a sweeten coffee, and filled with a sweet cream cheese mixture and topped with a dark chocolate frosting and ganach
  • Strawberry or Peach Filled—2 layers of white cake filled with fresh fruit and topped with a sweet flavored gelatin glaze and frosting with white frosting
  • Pumpkin Torte—6 layers of thin pumpkin cake with a cream cheese frosting

Other Desserts:

  • Tiramisu
  • Lemon Lush

*Please ask for additional seasonal selections

Try the Hershey Pantry for any Baking Needs and Holidays!! Contact us for more information.

Events, Etc.